The reasons for the same are revealed in the show’s third season after viewers become aware that Beth cannot bear children. As Beth’s romantic relationship with Rip gets serious, she begins to worry that Rip will resent her for not being able to have a child.
Ever since, Beth has lamented the fact she can’t ever have kids of her own, which has caused unrest in her one-again-off-again relationship with Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser). The loyal ranch hand finally became Beth’s fiancé at the end of season three, and an unexpected twist could reveal how the couple will be able to raise a son after all.
As a result, she can’t have children, and Rip (it was his baby, which he never knew about), still doesn’t know so that reveal has to be coming at some point. John was (understandably) very upset when Beth made this reveal and screamed at Jamie for making such a horrifying decision for his sister.
“Watching Beth watch Rip & Tate I’m having the feeling at one time Beth Dutton was pregnant with Rip’s baby. She hadn’t told him yet and Jamie caused her to lose the baby and her ability to have any more,” this theory by a fan remains to be the most probable one.
Beth grew up on Yellowstone Dutton Ranch and has three brothers – Kayce, Lee and Jamie. Lee died during a feud with the Broken Rock Indian Reservation.
Why Can’t Beth Have a Baby on Yellowstone? In ‘Yellowstone,’ fans see that Beth has a contentious relationship with her brother Jamie Dutton. The reasons for the same are revealed in the show’s third season after viewers become aware that Beth cannot bear children.
While Rip says it doesn’t matter to him whether he builds a legacy or not, Beth clearly is not okay. It is evident that she wants to have children. She adores Tate (Kayce and Monica’s son) and wishes she had a child of her own and it shows in the way she longingly looks at the young boy.
ADVERTISEMENT
